😉 The "Trust Syrup Loophole" 🥃 : Why Being Honest About Your Product’s Flaws Could Pay Off!

In partnership with

How did the worst-tasting cold medicine become the top-selling cough syrup in Canada?

It has to do with the sneaky marketing loophole I want to share with you today…

It’s a principle you can use to spin a negative feature of your brand or product into a powerful, persuasive reason to buy.

This marketing trick comes courtesy of Buckley’s cough syrup… 

The Buckley family had been in the cough syrup business for over two generations. 

Despite decades in the cold curing business, Buckely’s syrup had barely cracked the top 10 cough syrup brands in Canada.

Why?

Buckley’s syrup tasted gross, and it wasn’t a secret.

The company was known for having the worst-tasting cough syrup in Canada. 

And Canada is practically a land of syrup. So, this is a pretty serious claim.

Enter marketing maverick, Peter Byrne…

In a situation like this, where a product is known for tasting bad, most marketers would do everything they can to hide this fact.

But Byrne knew better. Here’s what he did instead…

Rather than hide the fact that the medicine tasted like rotting fruit, he called it out in their marketing:

 It tastes awful, and it works.

With this “negative” message, the Buckley’s brand launched one of the most successful marketing campaigns in Canadian history.

In just over five years, the Buckleys jumped from number 10 in the cough suppressant category to number 1.

Frank Buckley, the company owner, even agreed to be the campaign's spokesman, publicly expressing how bad his product tasted.

So why did this campaign work so well?

Peter Byrne understood a marketing concept called “the power of the negative.”

Or the “yucky cough syrup secret,” as I like to call it.

The idea is that highlighting something negative about your product builds trust with your audience.

Of course, this has to be done the right way.

Simply trashing your product is a fast track to going out of business.

The key to making the “yucky cough syrup secret” work is to use the negative aspect to highlight something positive about your product. 

In the case of Buckely’s syrup, they used the fact that it tasted bad to highlight that it was really good at treating colds.

It tastes awful = negative.

And it works = suuuper positive. 

Because the Buckelys were so honest about their syrup tasting bad, people were more likely to trust their claim that the product worked well.  

Leading with something negative supercharges the positive benefit you mention afterward.

People can trust you more if you’re honest about your product’s flaws… something most marketers and business owners aren’t.

It works for gross cough syrup and can also work for your brand.

Happy Marketing!

Evelio